Our primary defense against the outside world is our immune system. It is a complex system created with the sole purpose of protecting our bodies from various foreign invaders. Over many years of evolution, it has become particularly good at identifying, isolating, and eliminating potential threats. However, what if those same defenses turned on us? What happens when the immune system can no longer tell the difference between friend or foe? This occurs during autoimmune conditions, when the immune system attacks one’s own cells and tissues. To date, several disorders are linked to this condition; one example brought to light recently occurs during the onset of type 1 diabetes (T1D) in children. Evidence that regulatory CD4+ T cells (Tregs) suppress the activation of autoreactive T cells and maintain self tolerance has led to the hypothesis that Treg dysfunction is a major factor underlying the development of T1D (Sakaguchi et al.)
The best characterized Tregs are those that express the FOXP3 transcription factor, but although FOXP3 appears to be an accurate marker of Tregs in mice, it is also expressed by activated nonsuppressive T cells in humans (Ziegler et al.) This research, reported in the Journal of Immunology, demonstrated how dysfunctional Tregs are a key contributor to the onset of T1D in children. In humans, it has been shown that nonsuppressed T cells express a transcription factor FOXP3 and it has been established that cells that overexpress IL-17 can lead to T1D (Marwaha at el.) T1D patients have been shown to have elevated levels of IL-17-producing cells but there was no relevance shown. Recently other research groups have shown that cells that express FOXP3 can produce IL-17, and that Treg cells can transform into IL-17-producing cells (Voo et al.) This lead to a further discovery that a specific subset of Treg cells can avoid suppression and produce IL-17. This type of cell is known as (CD45RA-, CD25int, FOXP3low). In this study, it is shown that populations of this particular subset is increased in patients with the onset of T1D. Overall, it is evident from this research that our greatest defense can also be our greatest threat if not regulated properly. Although this discovery could benefit T1D patients in the future, researchers have yet to come up with a strategy to circumvent this regulatory dysfunction.
I work in the field of childhood diabetes research. I must say that the issue of regulatory cells in type 1 diabetes is not as straightforward as it may sound from some of the studies. There are actually lots of studies, and in vivo results were sometimes contradictory to in vitro results and so were results in mice models compared to human studies. The work of a group from California, for example, showed that tolerance to a systemic antigen is independent of regulatory cells (1). Note that regulatory cells exist in various phenotypes (both as natural and ‘adaptive’ or induced) with different mechanisms of action [reviewed in (2) and (3)]. One important issue to consider in the evaluation of Treg cells is that some populations act through direct cell-cell contact making the examination of local affected tissue (islet β cells in case of T1D) mandatory. Also, a B cell subset (CD1dhi CD5+) with regulatory function has been suggested recently (regulates T cell function through IL-10 secretion) (4). It seems that detailed knowledge of regulatory cells kinetics, exact time points when they become activated, events that follow activation, role of cytokines (TGF-β, CTLA-4 and IL-10) and APC’s (DC’s) and degree of efficiency in suppressing T effector/memory function are needed before a satisfactory answer can be concluded.
ReplyDelete1. Barron L, Knoechel B, Lohr J and Abbas Abul K. Cutting the edge: contributions of apoptosis and anergy to systemic antigen tolerance. The journal of immunology 2008; 180: 2762-2766.
2. Homann D and Von Herrath M. Short analytical review: Regulatory T cells and type 1 diabetes. Clinical immunology 2004; 112: 202-209.
3. Jaeckel E, Mpofu N, Saal N and Maans MP. Role of regulatory T cells for the treatment of type 1 diabetes mellitus. Horm Metab Res 2008; 40: 126-136.
4. A regulatory B cell subset with a unique CD1dhiCD25+ phenotype controls T cell-dependent inflammatory responses. Immunity 2008; 28: 639-650.